Hello,
According to what you write, the land is co-owned by you and your ex-spouse, which you acquired on the basis of a donation agreement from your mother. Due to your ex-husband’s lack of care for the land, as well as your ex-husband’s lack of interest in your mother, your mother wants the gift to be returned to her.
We would like to point out that according to the provisions of Section 630 of the Civil Code, the following applies:
“The donor may demand the return of the gift if the donee behaves towards him or members of his family in such a way that he grossly violates good morals.”
It follows from this legal provision that only the donor, i.e. your mother, has the right to request the return of the gift and only in the case of a gross violation of good morals, for example in the form of physical assault on the donor. Unfortunately, lack of interest alone is not a sufficient reason to return the gift. We are also convinced that neglect of the care of the land by the donee is not a reason to return the donor’s gift. In the case of lack of interest in the care of the land, it is a relationship between the co-owners that needs to be resolved between them. There is a possibility of voluntary return of the donor’s donation based on an agreement. Another option is an agreement on the dissolution and settlement of co-ownership, where you, as the ex-wife, would acquire your ex-spouse’s share in accordance with the provision of Section 141 of the Civil Code, or you could buy this share for an agreed price. Another alternative is for your ex-husband to donate a share of the land to your children as well. We recommend contacting a lawyer to arrange ownership rights to the land. Of course, you can also use the services of our law firm to resolve this matter.
