Úvod › Právna poradňa

Dispute over the value of investments in a shared house

Otázka klienta

Almost 20 years ago, we reconstructed our grandparents' house together, where our grandmother and aunt lived, and we shared the costs of the reconstruction. After a few years, we divided the house between me and my aunt. But now she claims that she wants to sell the house and claims that at least 100,000 will belong to her because she has invested more than we have. We had the house evaluated and according to the report, the value is about € 90,400. Therefore, we offered to buy her half for €46,000, but she insists on selling the whole house. However, we would like to preserve the house, after all, my whole family has lived there for generations. Do we have to agree to the amount requested? She claims that if we do not agree, she will dismantle what she bought there, according to her claims. If she is not willing to negotiate with us, we can really take away the material (windows, truss structure, etc.), as it has been a long time ago, we have some documents about the reconstruction, but probably not all of them.

Odpoveď právničky

Hello, from the above question, we believe that if you and your aunt have divided the house in such a way, the house in question is in your co-ownership, and as you write yourself and we assume that each of you owns 1/2 of the size.

The following provisions of the Civil Code apply to your situation:

Joint ownership
§ 137

(1) The share expresses the extent to which the co-owners participate in the rights and obligations arising from the joint ownership of the common property.
(2) Unless otherwise stipulated by law or agreed by the parties, the shares of all co-owners shall be equal.

§ 140

If the co-ownership share is transferred, the co-owners have a right of pre-emption, unless it is a transfer to a close person (Sections 116, 117). If the co-owners do not agree on the exercise of the right of pre-emption, they have the right to buy out the share in proportion to the size of the shares.

§ 141

(1) The co-owners may agree on the dissolution of co-ownership and on mutual settlement; if the subject of co-ownership is immovable property, the agreement must be in writing.
(2) Each of the co-owners is obliged to issue to the others a written confirmation of how they have settled on request, if the agreement on the dissolution of co-ownership and on mutual settlement did not already have a written form.
§ 142

(1) If no agreement is reached, the court shall dissolve the co-ownership and carry out the settlement at the request of one of the co-owners. It will take into account the size of the shares and the purposeful use of the property. If the division of the property is not possible, the court will order the case to one or more co-owners for reasonable compensation; In doing so, it will take into account the fact that the thing can be used purposefully and the violent behaviour of the co-owner towards the other co-owners. If none of the co-owners wants the property, the court will order its sale and divide the proceeds according to shares.

Of course, you do not have to agree with the price that your aunt asks for the house. If you do not agree on a reasonable price, you can seek a lawsuit for the cancellation and settlement of joint ownership under the above provisions. If you can prove that you are co-owners, both parties have appreciated the property and the prices of the reconstruction have been approximately the same, the court could award you the property for reasonable compensation (approximately half of the value of the house).

When deciding on the settlement, the court will first determine whether the house is divisible. If it is not, then it examines whether any of the co-owners of the house want to take ownership. If you want a house, the court can assign it to you with the obligation to pay half of the value of the house.

Before the commencement of court proceedings, it is advisable to send a written request to the aunt for the dissolution and settlement of the joint ownership and to propose adequate compensation for her share on the basis of an expert opinion.

JUDr. Adriana Ručkayová
Autor odpovede
JUDr. Adriana Ručkayová

Som advokátka a zakladateľka AKR. Špecializujem sa na občianske a obchodné právo — pomáham klientom nájsť zrozumiteľné riešenia v kľúčových momentoch ich života.

Riešite podobnú právnu otázku?

Opíšte váš prípad v právnej poradni — odpovieme do 48 hodín. Alebo si dohodnite konzultáciu a preberieme to osobne.