Hello. Your question focuses on the institute of donation and specifically on the possibility of returning the gift. It follows from your question that in connection with the ownership rights to the subject of the gift, which is the apartment, there was a gradual transfer of ownership by gift. During this process, your ex-husband first donated the apartment to your son, and later your son donated the apartment to you.
According to the donation agreement, there is a transfer of ownership. This form of contract obliges the donor to provide the donee with a certain thing or things voluntarily and free of charge, while the donee accepts this item. A donation agreement is the most common example of a gratuitous contract where the donor does not accept any property consideration for the donated item. In addition to free of charge, voluntariness is also important, which means that the gift is not provided on the basis of a legal obligation arising from another contract or law. A donation agreement is a bilateral legal act that requires an offer of a donation by the donor and the acceptance of that offer by the donee.
General about donation
The donation agreement is regulated relatively strictly in our legal system, namely in the provisions of Sections 628 to 630 of the Civil Code.
According to the provision of Section 628 of the Civil Code, the following applies: “(1) By means of a donation agreement, the donor leaves or promises something to the donee free of charge and accepts the gift or promise. (2) The donation contract must be in writing if the subject of the donation is real estate, and in the case of movable property, if the thing is not handed over and taken over during the donation. (3) A donation contract according to which it is to be performed only after the donor’s death is invalid.”
According to the provision of Section 629 of the Civil Code, the following applies: “When offering a gift, the donor is obliged to point out defects of which he is aware. If the item has defects that the donor did not point out, the donee is entitled to return the item.”
According to the provision of Section 630 of the Civil Code, the following applies: “The donor may demand the return of the gift if the donee behaves towards him or members of his family in such a way that he grossly violates good morals.”
The return of a gift is a legal institute that is regulated in the provision of Section 630 of the Civil Code and represents a special way of terminating a legal relationship that has arisen as a result of a donation. It allows the donor to request the return of the gift in the event that the donee grossly violates good morals towards the donor or his family.
According to the law, only the behavior of the recipient that has actually and objectively manifested itself is relevant, not the subjective belief of the donor. Requesting the return of a gift is a unilateral legal act of the donor, which is aimed at the recipient returning the gift. The law does not regulate the form of this act, but in the case of real estate, the request for the return of the gift should be in writing.
The donor may request the return of the gift only in the event of a gross violation of good morals by the recipient. A gross violation of good morals is understood as a continuous or significant violation. In practice, this may include physical violence or gross insults against the donor or their family.
The law does not regulate the method of returning the gift, but if the donee does not want to return the gift, the donor must assert his claim in court before the expiry of the three-year limitation period. In court proceedings, the donor must prove that the legal prerequisites for the return of the gift under Section 630 of the Civil Code are met.
According to the question, your son would have to demand the return of the gift against you. To succeed in requesting the return of the gift, he would have to prove that you grossly violated good manners towards him or his family members. This gross violation of good morals would have to directly affect your son or his family members. However, if this legal prerequisite does not exist and cannot be proven even in possible court proceedings, the request for the return of the gift cannot be successful.
